# Thinking about Digital Publishing > Some implications of "digital" for scholarly communication ## Posts - [Two cultures](https://consultmu.co.uk/two-cultures/): C P Snow wrote about two cultures, the arts and the sciences, who don’t understand each other. - [The Charleston Conference 2026](https://consultmu.co.uk/the-charleston-conference-2026/): Conferences, even those in the South Carolina autumn sunshine at 26 degrees Celsius (79 degrees F), are a good opportunity to look at what issues are exercising the minds of those in scholarly communications. - [Caroline Ball: an activist perspective](https://consultmu.co.uk/caroline-ball-an-activist-perspective/): Caroline Ball, who I interviewed on the ATG Podcast, has had a career of engagement with users: from working in a public library, to a trustee of Wikipedia UK, and her present role, as Community Engagement Lead with the Open Book Collective. - [Peter Brantley on the role of the library](https://consultmu.co.uk/peter-brantley-on-the-role-of-the-library/): Peter Brantley (talking recently in an interview on the ATG Podcast) has been involved with the interaction between publishing and technology ever since studying sociology at university. - [A sustainability plan for repositories](https://consultmu.co.uk/a-sustainability-plan-for-repositories/): Institutional Repositories were typically founded ten or twenty years ago, and today have reached a kind of maturity. - [How a library publishing program benefits an institution](https://consultmu.co.uk/how-a-library-publishing-program-benefits-an-institution/): What does a library publishing program actually do—and why are more universities creating them? - [Elizabeth Gadd: metrics aren’t the whole story](https://consultmu.co.uk/elizabeth-gadd-metrics-arent-the-whole-story/): When people talk about research quality, they often jump straight to numbers: citations, impact factors, H-indices, and rankings. - [The future of the book](https://consultmu.co.uk/the-future-of-the-book/): Here was an intriguing subject for a webinar, with the challenging title, The Future of the Book: Timeless or Time-Challenged? - [Daniel Dollar on the role of the scholarly library](https://consultmu.co.uk/daniel-dollar-on-the-role-of-the-scholarly-library/): Daniel Dollar’s career has covered a wide range of information management and retrieval. - [How libraries can experiment with AI](https://consultmu.co.uk/how-libraries-can-experiment-with-ai/): Small libraries face the same challenges as larger institutions, but with fewer resources, which is why it was so fascinating to talk for ATGthePodcast with Russell “Rusty” Michalak, Library Director at Goldey-Beacom College in Delaware. - [Orland Hoeber: how to use AI in the loop](https://consultmu.co.uk/orland-hoeber-how-to-use-ai-in-the-loop/): Orland Hoeber (University of Regina, Canada) has spent much of his academic career looking at why and how we search for scholarly content. - [Ben Lee, Digital Humanities teacher and researcher  ](https://consultmu.co.uk/ben-lee-digital-humanities-teacher-and-researcher/): Ben Lee teaches on the library master’s course at the University of Washington, including AI literacy, as well as editing a scholarly journal, Digital Humanities Quarterly. - [The Trip Database](https://consultmu.co.uk/the-trip-database/): Trip is that rare exception, a David in a world of Goliaths. - [Shadow Libraries : a lesson for us all](https://consultmu.co.uk/shadow-libraries-a-lesson-for-us-all/): The books may be there, but can you access them? - [Will genAI replace Wikipedia?](https://consultmu.co.uk/will-genai-replace-wikipedia/): A print edition of the 11th edition of Encyclopaedia Britannica. Nice to see they have an entry for "mum" – I always thought she deserved one. - [The benefits of a small language model (SLM)](https://consultmu.co.uk/the-benefits-of-a-small-language-model-slm/): It was a moment of pure geekdom. - [Interview with Allison Belan, Duke University Press](https://consultmu.co.uk/interview-with-allison-belan-duke-university-press/): How can a university press survive and flourish when faced with constant technical change and increasingly monolithic commercial competition? - [Are timelines value-free?](https://consultmu.co.uk/are-timelines-value-free/): Rosenberg and Grafton’s Cartographies of Time (2010) is a lovely book to look at. It has an elegant design, and is illustrated in four colour throughout. - [The library as an active learning hub](https://consultmu.co.uk/the-library-as-an-active-learning-hub/): Helen Bischoff gave a fascinating and inspiring presentation at the last Charleston Conference: how the library can become an active learning hub. - [The timeline](https://consultmu.co.uk/the-timeline/): Timelines are so ubiquitous, we take for granted how they work, and we assume they have always been around. - [How the library has become an innovator in digital literacy](https://consultmu.co.uk/how-the-library-has-become-an-innovator-in-digital-literacy/): If you thought being a librarian was just licensing content and shelving books, then think again. - [The Library Partnership Rating: a new way to evaluate academic publishers?](https://consultmu.co.uk/the-library-partnership-rating-a-new-way-to-evaluate-academic-publishers/): Libraries and publishers interact all the time, but how can a library communicate its vision for scholarly publishing? - [The Fiesole Retreat in Tübingen](https://consultmu.co.uk/the-fiesole-retreat-in-tubingen/): If you are seeking a sense of tradition, here was where to find it. - [Failure in science](https://consultmu.co.uk/failure-in-science/): This fascinating one-day event, at Imperial College, London, looked at failure from many angles. - [Lazy definitions in the digital era](https://consultmu.co.uk/lazy-definitions-in-the-digital-era/): One unexpected aspect of digital publishing is the increasing misuse of links. - [Understanding Research Impact and Metrics: Insights from the library](https://consultmu.co.uk/understanding-research-impact-and-metrics-insights-from-the-library/): Universities spend considerable time and money trying to measure research influence, but do those metrics truly capture scholarly value? - [A not very revolutionary history of science](https://consultmu.co.uk/a-not-very-revolutionary-history-of-science/): The chance to hear Nobel prize-winner Paul Nurse speak (at the Ernst Chain Memorial Lecture, Imperial College) was too good to miss. - [Exploring the future of community-led open access books: the 2026 Copim Conference](https://consultmu.co.uk/exploring-the-future-of-community-led-open-access-books-the-2026-copim-conference/): What is a conference for? - [A Cambridge publishing success story](https://consultmu.co.uk/a-cambridge-publishing-success-story/): It may surprise some that there is more than one academic book publisher in Cambridge. - [Two contrasting views of science](https://consultmu.co.uk/two-contrasting-views-of-science/): Not all scientists are like Darwin. - [Gregory Laynor: from Gertrude Stein to systematic reviews](https://consultmu.co.uk/gregory-laynor-from-gertrude-stein-to-systematic-reviews/): Meta-Research, or research about research, has existing for many years, but only recently has it started to be identified more formally. - [Using genAI for the literature review](https://consultmu.co.uk/using-genai-for-the-literature-review/): Is there any point in doing a literature review now that genAI can do it for you? - [Andrew Smeall: using technology to effect business change](https://consultmu.co.uk/andrew-smeall-using-technology-to-effect-business-change/): Adaptability and innovation are words that spring to mind with Andrew Smeall. - [How a lab research scientist works](https://consultmu.co.uk/how-a-lab-research-scientist-works/): What motivates a research scientist? How does a researcher choose their topics? What’s their view of preprints and open science? - [Ghost references cause many genAI errors](https://consultmu.co.uk/ghost-references-cause-many-genai-errors/): Ghost references are links that have not been validated. - [Does genAI define terms better than humans do?](https://consultmu.co.uk/does-genai-define-terms-better-than-humans-do/): One of the most impressive capabilities of genAI is the ability to summarise and to define terms. - [Herbert Van de Sompel interviewed](https://consultmu.co.uk/herbert-van-de-sompel-interviewed/): Herbert van de Sompel, recently interviewed for the ATG Podcast, describes himself, somewhat modestly, as an “infrastructure plumber” rather than a librarian. - [Using genAI to read books](https://consultmu.co.uk/using-genai-to-read-books/): The dreaded reading list. Which to read first? Which to skim? Why these books? - [A free institutional repository conference](https://consultmu.co.uk/a-free-institutional-repository-conference/): The MIRL Conference (November) is just what a user-based conference should be: a series of case studies, with repository managers willing to share what worked, and at times, what didn’t work, with their peers. - [Search in an age of AI](https://consultmu.co.uk/search-in-an-age-of-ai/): There is an endearing air of disorganisation about the Search Solutions Conference: even though it has been running for over 20 years, it continues to have an unscripted feel. - [An interview with Brian Nosek, Center for Open Science](https://consultmu.co.uk/an-interview-with-brian-nosek-center-for-open-science/): The Center for Open Science, co-founded by Brian Nosek, has been responsible for many of the big innovations in science practice over the last ten years, including the Open Science Framework and the Reproducibility Project. - [Lab Girl](https://consultmu.co.uk/lab-girl/): Lab Girl is a triumphant tale of a scientist who succeeds in becoming a researcher and creating her own lab, against the odds for a woman struggling against a male-dominated research culture. - [SciELO: a model for Open Science?](https://consultmu.co.uk/scielo-a-model-for-open-science/): Anyone with an interest in Open Science and the role of repositories will find the ATG interview with Abel Packer, co-founder of SciELO, fascinating. - [Annotation: the scholarly goldmine](https://consultmu.co.uk/annotation-the-scholarly-goldmine/): The literature review is one of the core components of the scholarly lifecycle. To begin your research, you see what has been said and done. - [Fighting for the humanities](https://consultmu.co.uk/fighting-for-the-humanities/): Anyone with an interest in humanities studies in the US will have heard of the current struggles over funding and the National Endowment of the Humanities. - [Have LLMs overtaken humans for knowledge organization?](https://consultmu.co.uk/have-llms-overtaken-humans-for-knowledge-organization/): If they have, you might not have thought so from the ISKO-UK annual conference (7 October 2025). - [Goodreads: is it good for reading?](https://consultmu.co.uk/goodreads-is-it-good-for-reading/): It is a commonplace that the act of reading is a worthy use of your time. - [Can a new format breathe life into the TLS?](https://consultmu.co.uk/can-a-new-format-breathe-life-into-the-tls/): The TLS, from a sans-serif to a serif title: is this significant? - [Philip Ball: How Life Works](https://consultmu.co.uk/philip-ball-how-life-works/): How Life Works is a fascinating read: how successful is it as an example of science communication? - [How to carry out a survey: Open-Access monographs](https://consultmu.co.uk/how-to-carry-out-a-survey-open-access-monographs/): Scholarly publishing loves surveys. - [What is the use of a book without pictures?](https://consultmu.co.uk/what-is-the-use-of-a-book-without-pictures/): A 2025 paper by Olof Sundin worries about people using Google Search uncritically. - [A selective updating tool for researchers](https://consultmu.co.uk/a-selective-updating-tool-for-researchers/): A few months ago, I had the pleasure of interviewing Thomas Krichel, about his role in setting up RePEc, the working paper repository for economics. - [Damian Pattinson on the eLife model](https://consultmu.co.uk/damian-pattinson-on-the-elife-model/): Damian Pattinson’s interview for the ATG Podcast has just been released, and it reveals some fascinating details about his background, and about the eLife publishing model. - [John Willinsky and the Public Knowledge Project](https://consultmu.co.uk/john-willinsky-and-the-public-knowledge-project/): I recently interviewed John Willinsky, best-known for the Public Knowledge Project. - [How to Review Scholarly Books](https://consultmu.co.uk/how-to-review-scholarly-books/): Steven Gump’s book How to Review Scholarly Books, published just a few weeks ago (June 2025), is a very timely work: it tells you how to write a scholarly review. - [The Charleston In-Between Conference](https://consultmu.co.uk/the-charleston-in-between-conference/): This event, for the first time in hybrid format, comprising two half-days in the middle of a hot Berlin summer, proved remarkably feisty, which is perhaps not surprising considering the issues being discussed, notably changing government attitudes to scientific research (one panel was accurately entitled “Libraries under fire: Defending scholarship in a time of political pressure”). - [Research culture, as told by a scientist](https://consultmu.co.uk/research-culture-as-told-by-a-scientist/): When we advocate open science, do we think about what scientists do? - [Yes, AI has reached human levels](https://consultmu.co.uk/yes-ai-has-reached-human-levels/): AGI, or artificial general intelligence, has been the holy grail of AI for many years. - [In praise of the manual](https://consultmu.co.uk/in-praise-of-the-manual/): Halliwell’s Film Guide is a collection of film reviews, first published 1977, and reprinted many times over at least 25 years. - [The Fiesole Retreat 2025](https://consultmu.co.uk/the-fiesole-retreat-2025/): It’s undeniable that some conferences have a special atmosphere. - [The perfect encyclopedia entry](https://consultmu.co.uk/the-perfect-encyclopedia-entry/): During several years of creating, editing, publishing, and revising dictionaries and encyclopedias, I produced guidance for my team of editors on what constitutes the perfect reference article. - [Wikipedia should not link to primary research](https://consultmu.co.uk/wikipedia-should-not-link-to-primary-research/): Wikipedia is where we go first to look something up: you use it when you know nothing about a subject. - [What is research culture?](https://consultmu.co.uk/what-is-research-culture/): The concept “research culture” didn’t apparently exist until a few years ago. According to the Google ngram viewer, it only began around 1980. - [Facts and myths about institutional repositories](https://consultmu.co.uk/facts-and-myths-about-institutional-repositories/): Who knows about repositories? - [Digital content is addling our brains](https://consultmu.co.uk/digital-content-is-addling-our-brains/): John Burns-Murdoch, in the Financial Times, is the latest to make this claim (“Have humans passed peak brain power?”, FT, 14 March 2025). - [The 2025 Researcher to Reader Conference](https://consultmu.co.uk/the-2025-researcher-to-reader-conference/): This was the tenth Researcher to Reader (R2R) Conference, ably led and chaired by Mark Carden. Why is it different to other events? - [What is Open Science?](https://consultmu.co.uk/what-is-open-science/): There are some words and phrases that seem to evade the normal processes of lexicographic assessment: they turn out to have many meanings. - [Nine rules for a startup](https://consultmu.co.uk/nine-rules-for-a-startup/): Phil Gooch, founder of the successful startup Scholarcy, was the highlight of the first-ever AI, Publishing and EdTech Meetup (London, February 2025). - [Google Search drives few visits to repositories: should we be worried?](https://consultmu.co.uk/google-search-drives-few-visits-to-repositories-should-we-be-worried/): The Google Search home screen: is this where academics start their research? - [What we really want from genAI and search engines](https://consultmu.co.uk/what-we-really-want-from-genai-and-search-engines/): Search engines have not become obsolete because of genAI. They serve different purposes, and it’s worth while considering how they differ. - [What researchers and students actually do](https://consultmu.co.uk/what-researchers-and-students-actually-do/): The UKSG Forum (Birmingham, 5 December 2024) provided some remarkably informative sessions about AI, from the perspective from the library, as well as from researchers. - [When to use genAI now](https://consultmu.co.uk/when-to-use-genai-now/): Ethan Mollick, whose One Useful Thing posts are always readable, suggested 15 immediate uses for GenAI. - [Typography: a very short introduction](https://consultmu.co.uk/typography-a-very-short-introduction/): I like the Very Short Introductions, which often give me an overview of a subject in just a few pages, so I was very enthusiastic to read Typography: A very short introduction (2018). - [Where next for genAI? What the professionals think](https://consultmu.co.uk/where-next-for-genai-what-the-professionals-think/): If the Search Solutions conference is to be believed, there isn’t much hope for genAI. - [Discovering content in repositories](https://consultmu.co.uk/discovering-content-in-repositories/): How do students and researchers find content? This is a topic that comes up again and again in this column, since it seems to be so frequently misunderstood. - [How AI is being adopted in scholarly publishing](https://consultmu.co.uk/how-ai-is-being-adopted-in-scholarly-publishing/): You don’t need telling that there is a multiplicity of views on AI in scholarly publishing. - [How to get PIDs adopted](https://consultmu.co.uk/how-to-get-pids-adopted/): We all agree on the benefits of using PIDs, persistent identifiers, the use of standard metadata such as DOIs for objects, ORCIDs for people, RORs for institutions) to reduce ambiguity and to maximise interoperability. - [They do things differently there ](https://consultmu.co.uk/they-do-things-differently-there/): Alphabetical order: better or worse? - [Economics Working Papers: a model for open science?](https://consultmu.co.uk/economics-working-papers-a-model-for-open-science/): I recently interviewed Thomas Krichel, founder of RePEc, the content repository for economics. - [The Alignment Problem (Brian Christian)](https://consultmu.co.uk/the-alignment-problem-brian-christian/): The Alignment Problem (2020) is an excellent resource for anyone seeking a clear and informed view of the limitations, as well as the opportunities, of current AI tools. - [Generative AI and the library](https://consultmu.co.uk/generative-ai-and-the-library/): The current issue of Against the Grain (July 5 2024) contains two contrasting pieces about the use of generative AI for scholarly discovery. - [How to reach a consensus](https://consultmu.co.uk/how-to-reach-a-consensus/): Are they all singing from the same song sheet? - [How to read non-fiction](https://consultmu.co.uk/how-to-read-non-fiction/): Karin Wulf, a well-known history academic, who effectively straddles the divide between academic and popular writing, revealed her methodology for appraising an academic work in an interesting post, a process she calls efficient reading. - [How to assess the societal impact of open science](https://consultmu.co.uk/how-to-assess-the-societal-impact-of-open-science/): Can we assess societal impact at all? Or are we asking the wrong question? - [A History of Reading](https://consultmu.co.uk/a-history-of-reading/): I can’t resist a book that proposes to tell me about the history of reading. - [Predictions for Generative AI](https://consultmu.co.uk/predictions-for-generative-ai/): In a fascinating post, Ian Mulvaney of BMJ compared his predictions for AI from several months ago, with what actually happened. - [Do books influence digital culture?](https://consultmu.co.uk/do-books-influence-digital-culture/): I had high hopes for a post entitled “How books influence digital culture”. - [Has search found the answer yet?](https://consultmu.co.uk/has-search-found-the-answer-yet/): If you ask Google “What is the ugliest language in the world?” it will give you an answer (Kannada, according to Google, at least until 2021, when there was a minor scandal in the Indian media when Google’s response was revealed). - [Is Open Access Open Excess?](https://consultmu.co.uk/is-open-access-open-excess/): A remarkable comment (“Open excess: remove open access burden from REF”) on the UK Research Excellence Framework (REF) claims that open access is a burden on higher education. - [The Joy of Search](https://consultmu.co.uk/the-joy-of-search/): Daniel Russell was for over ten years the head of search at Google, so a book by him about search raises considerable expectations. - [Should scholarly societies outsource their publishing?](https://consultmu.co.uk/should-scholarly-societies-outsource-their-publishing/): There was an excellent presentation at this year’s UKSG Conference on scholarly society publishers, followed by a preprint article on Zenodo. - [The Role of the library in evaluating tools for scholarly workflow](https://consultmu.co.uk/the-role-of-the-library-in-evaluating-tools-for-scholarly-workflow/): A workshop at the UKSG Annual Conference 2024 revealed, I believe, a vital role for the institutional library. - [How not to index the Pevsner Architectural Guides](https://consultmu.co.uk/how-not-to-index-the-pevsner-architectural-guides/): Devotees of human indexing (see, for example, Dennis Duncan, Index, A History of the) might want to try looking up a place in index of the Pevsner Architectural Guides to Scotland, specifically, the volume for Dundee and Angus (by John Gifford, 2012). - [The UKSG Conference 2024](https://consultmu.co.uk/the-uksg-conference-2024/): All conferences follow a similar format. - [Do we need speed cameras for research integrity?](https://consultmu.co.uk/do-we-need-speed-cameras-for-research-integrity/): In a provocative post on Scholarly Kitchen, Angela Cochran (VP of Publishing of one of the most prestigious scholarly societies, the American Society for Clinical Oncology) argues that societies should not be burdened with the additional expenditure of checking submitted articles for what are today called integrity errors – paper mills, evidence of plagiarism, and so on. - [Using AI in the Research Ecosystem](https://consultmu.co.uk/using-ai-in-the-research-ecosystem/): Conferences and presentations about AI are everywhere these days, but this half-day event, part of the AI UK Fringe 2024 workshop, which looked specifically at AI (both machine learning and generative AI) and its interaction with scholarly research, proved particularly worthwhile. - [The London Book Fair](https://consultmu.co.uk/the-london-book-fair/): For anyone whose interest is primarily scholarly publishing, the London Book Fair is a rather tantalizing affair. - [The Researcher to Reader Conference 2024](https://consultmu.co.uk/the-researcher-to-reader-conference-2024/): How one university got three different results to the question "how many OA articles did we publish in 2022?" Graphic by Ben Rawlins of University of Kentucky. - [The Second Digital Transformation of Scholarly Publishing](https://consultmu.co.uk/the-second-digital-transformation-of-scholarly-publishing/): This lengthy report (some 20,000 words) is quite a challenge to review. - [Timeline of Library history](https://consultmu.co.uk/timeline-of-library-history/): I noticed a lack of any timeline of library history in the recent introduction The Library: A Fragile History (2022), and I didn't see one in Wikipedia either, so here is a suggested starting point. ## Pages - [Popular posts](https://consultmu.co.uk/1452-2/) - [Tips for creating a reference publication](https://consultmu.co.uk/ten-tips-for-compiling-a-reference-work/): Reference works, from A-Z encyclopedias to short subject dictionaries, published online or in print, have many characteristics in common. - [About me](https://consultmu.co.uk/about-me/): I have been working for long enough in digital publishing to have reflected on the whole academic workflow. - [About reference content](https://consultmu.co.uk/about-reference-works/): You don't use reference content the way you read a novel, and that is true both of print and digital manifestations: reference is navigated differently. [comment]: # (Generated by Hostinger Tools Plugin)